I think the NET will always confuse me. Dayton, who is 0-5 in Quads 1 & 2, and 4-7 in Quads 1, 2, and 3, is somehow at 69. Now they don't have a Quad 4 loss, as VCU does. However, VCU is 2-3 in Quads 1 & 2, and is 6-4 in Quads 1, 2, and 3. The two teams NET SOS is almost identical, and our SOS using the RPI is much better.
I get that efficiency ratings play a role, but isn't winning and losing and strength of schedule the ultimate barometer?
I think NET confuses a lot of people, including those who try to predict the NCAA bracket too early in the year.
When the old RPI was around, it was easy to figure. People understood it. NET, which changes (improves?) a lot, really can't be looked at too early.
I used to look at the RPI daily starting in January. But with the NET, I just see no reason to look too early. But I did look today when I had some time.
Here is what I found about VCUs current position. We are at 80. We currently have one Q1 win and one Q4 loss. To me, the Q4 loss hurts more than the lack of Q1 wins. Hopefully, Jacksonville will help by winning a few more games.
At 80, I see 17 teams ahead of us that have only Q1 win, and 11 that have NONE. Those teams, like all teams, are still playing. A lot of those teams will not have the chance to play another Q1 team, but have some Q3 and Q4 teams left on their schedules. There are a couple ahead of us that have a losing record. I think we have a great chance to move up. And with some help, move up a lot.
We can also move up because a lot of the teams ahead of us will drop as the season continues. When these teams play each other, one has to lose. With time, that will take care of itself.
I don't buy the notion that winning the A-10 regular season outright will not help us. The winner of the A-10 regular season has been in the NCAA Tournament every year since we got in the A-10. Two were from winning the A-10 tournament. The other seven were granted at-large bids. So I want to win the #1 seed, outright. While it is not a guarantee, it must pull some weight. To win will require that we keep winning. But sorry, I hope that Dayton and St. Louis lose a game here or there, just to give us some breathing room. They don't have to win every game to keep their NET up. The NET Quad System is a range, not a single number. They both can lose a game here or there, win the rest, and give us a better shot when they play us. But still, I want some error room for slipping, just in case.
I still think we will end with a net in the mid 50s or better. A 55 and sitting at the top of the A-10 alone will do the trick.