- Joined
- Feb 21, 2010
- Posts
- 696
- Likes
- 1,042
Well stating facts can sometimes be hurtful. Stating facts that are hurtful that serve no real purpose are simply hurtful statements.I think there are two separate issues some are merging as one. Stating valid facts and being negative are two separate matters. I'm not sure how if a post isn't glowingly positive it's considered negative.
Which posts would you consider to be "negative?" And are you suggesting blind optimism 24/7?
In this situation you have a recruit who isn't rated with little evidence of an impressive offer list, I don't see why being neutral is unreasonable unless somebody is deep into the recruiting weeds and has seen the kid's talent or potential first hand.
And Pollyanna noticed
Lol! Well. Let's be accurate. I've only used the phrase "generational talent" in conjuction with one 2023 prospect - Elmarko Jackson...and I said he would be a general talent in the context of VCU history. It is an accurate statement because Elmarko is a 4* consensus Top 25-30 prospect who has thus far visiting places like Miami, Kansas, Texas thus weekend...VCU hasn't had anyone ranked that high since Kendrick Warren.Another generational talent?
asking for a friend
Understand objectivity, but sometimes you can't say something positive about anything on here without someone having to try to squash it. I've been there, done that, lived that way, wasn't very happy. Optimism is just a better way for me to live.I would rather spread objectivity (knowing that too is subjective). I don't see a problem with balance and I don't really see anything on this thread that is particularly out of bounds, unless the expectation is to believe every recruit who commits will be an all-time great (yeah, I'm looking at you DL).
Personally I welcome the kid and if MR sees something in him that he thinks will help the program I'm willing to wait and see (just like every recruit including the 4 stars). But let's be honest, unless you see everything through black and gold colored glasses is it realistic to expect fans to throw a parade for a recruit if the tangible info about him is pretty limited?
And I guarantee, if the kid blows up this season and creates a buzz, fan enthusiasm will elevate.
I get confused…we have a generation talent…a program changer.. a Len Bias upside guy…hard to keep all this straightLol! Well. Let's be accurate. I've only used the phrase "generational talent" in conjuction with one 2023 prospect - Elmarko Jackson...and I said he would be a general talent in the context of VCU history. It is an accurate statement because Elmarko is a 4* consensus Top 25-30 prospect who has thus far visiting places like Miami, Kansas, Texas thus weekend...VCU hasn't had anyone ranked that high since Kendrick Warren.
At the time, we were on him early and Bones with vcu members of Tressigang(Ace and Jamir) were lobbying him personally to come to VCU as late as mid August...
This is a sports forum. I don't think it's fair to draw parallels with how fans discuss and debate sports with how they live their lives.Understand objectivity, but sometimes you can't say something positive about anything on here without someone having to try to squash it. I've been there, done that, lived that way, wasn't very happy. Optimism is just a better way for me to live.
BTW, I don't think I've said anything about Ty that hasn't been objective. I see a guy who can do a lot of things we're looking for and has a lot of potential. Yes, it's still unfulfilled at D1 level. I say that from watching him play whole games against quality opposition, not from trying to figure out from his offer list which is honestly weak.
Still remember how we got hyped when he posterized CJ Leslie in high school.But is he Reco McCarter
I get confused…we have a generation talent…a program changer.. a Len Bias upside guy…hard to keep all this straight