I don't think your take, nor his take is a bad one.
First off he said more than likely gone.... not 100% gone. And well, statistically he's not wrong. How many players in the history of VCU Basketball have officially entered the transfer portal (even before the "Transfer Portal" became what it is now).... and how many have returned to VCU?
You're prob gonna be quick to say.... Max. Well he committed to Villanova.... the reason he returned to VCU (while unknown officially) was rumored to be NIL or something else. Whatever the case was.... if that hadn't happened..... Max wouldn't have come back.... so leave him out of this discussion for the moment.
Who else has officially entered the transfer portal & come back to VCU without committing to somewhere else first & there being an issue, that led to them returning to VCU.
The only other name that pops in my mind is Joey Rodriguez who left VCU, enrolled in some JuCo school or something? Forgot the name of it.... before coming back to VCU. Every other player not named Jennings or Max that I can think of who has entered the transfer portal... has left (To Be Dermined on Belle, Fats, Luke, Obi, as no official wording has come out about their final decision, only rumors)
Ace, Kern, Banks, Jamir, Deloach, Martin Carrere, Santos-Silva, Wheeler, Lawal, McAllister, Nunn, Ward, Jairus Lyles, PJ Byrd, Tsohonis, MBJ, Nichols, Medley-Bacon, Reco McCarter.... Michael Gilmore (tho he did transfer back a couple years later)
They all entered the portal for various reasons & they all left. At least when it comes to VCU.... the odds are, when you enter the portal..... you're gone & likely not coming back.
Yes, Jennings & his family are local to VCU, his mother attended & graduated from VCU according to multiple people. So yes they have ties to the school. But if they are 100% loyal to VCU, then why enter the transfer portal at all? Who the coach is, shouldn't matter.
I'll tell you why..... because the players don't commit to the SCHOOL..... they commit to the Coach. VCU didn't recruit Jennings.... the coaching staff did.
Jennings committed to Odom & his staff who just happened to be at VCU at the time. Odom left to take the UVA job..... and Jennings entered the portal and even took a visit to UVA. If you're "loyal to VCU" as you say.... why would he enter the portal & why would he take a visit to UVA & other schools for that matter? He wouldn't.
He made a business decision, a wise one at that imo.... to enter the portal, allow himself to gather offers & take visits..... as well as give himself a chance to see who this new coach is, what is this new coach like? Does this coach want me, or is he just gonna recruit over me? etc.
Which in the end, led him coming back to VCU..... which I & a lot of other Ram fans are happy about.
I don't think
@senor ram 's post is a poor take at all.... cause statistically.... the numbers heavily favor that once you enter the portal... you're likely not coming back.
Again.... To be determind on Belle, Fats, Luke & Obi, who could skew the #s back closer to possibly returning. But at the moment it's far from a 50/50 split.