No- I think you are dead-on. I've been a VCU basketball fan for my entire life. Almost 40 now, so I've been tuned in seriously about it since I was 7 or 8, and could go to all the games with my Dad. RAMification knows the recruiting piece of this thing like no other person I've ever met. He has the complete understanding about how "it" all works, and because of that, and of course the inevitable indoctrination, I think I too am a realist.
What you are saying here is spot-on. But here's what I am saying: Now you continue to build. That's it. Examples: OK. No more having to fill in a couple of barren spots with guys like Sam Faulk- who actually had to start for us much of one season. No more "project this," or "we-know something special that no-one else knows / that." We should not need to take gambles like that any more. What am I saying? Consistency.
You now have an opportunity to recruit that high-level, well thought-out, well-researched, high-upside 3-star type like the Eric Maynors / Dom Jones / Larry Sanders (although he was even a lower-level recruit). But those types of guys. You build now by gaining consistency, adding depth and tiering at every position / zone, and you just build a longer-term powerhouse of a program that continues to re-load the talent and layering levels- as opposed to having to completely rebuild.
Then you do this- You MUST go after some of the bigger fish- the 4-stars. The Michael Bradley types- and even better. Guess what? You'll land the occasional shark, while you continue to sign the big bad barracudas out there. And every few years, you're going to have a really nasty team with all sorts of damage potential- on a national scene.
Add to this the fact that you can also build some serious on-going chemistry and hopefully have a few teams like the 07' version of the RAMS that were just darn near impossible to "beat." Lots of JR & SR experience, skill, and confidence. If you had that one big fish, we would have made a final-4 run. That's what I am talking about. A general, subtle lift, and positive step in recruiting, with the big-hit potential here and there. Nothing more. But where we are, who we are, and what we do..... this elevation can take us from being close to a Top-25 program- to actually being a Top-25 program, which ultimately is my goal. We should be making a Top-25 appearance every 3 or 4 years. NCAA's every other, etc. Then you look at maybe the next level up.
Lastly, I will use as examples: Cincinnati of the late 80's and 90's. UNLV. Gonzaga. Georgetown back in the day before they were a power- and the Big East was not what it is today. Butler over the last several years. Saint Joes made a really special little run. Etc. Etc. I know it can be done. But you CAN NOT let the hard-work and momentum slip away. The time to build and charge forward is now. A lot of people are watching. I think some of the recruits we've been speaking to are a solid example of that.