I dont see any redshirts happening. How do you tell an all star kid he needs to redshirt after all the hype he has gone thru in recruiting? I dont know how our staff deals with it but I would let it be the players option with coaches approval.
Take the case of Rob B. ---he has been mentioned as a possible candidate before practice ever started (?) on this board because their are 8 guys vying for PT in three spots? Well if he did redshirt, it would be 7 for 3 spots and 8 for 3 spots again next year-same deal. If Grayson didnt redshirt, I dont think it will happen under Smart. The Hinton redshirt is entirely different beause you are dealing with a walk-on that was gauranteed nothing but a uniform.
Also a couple of injuries,poor grades, bad attitudes, etc. could devastate a team with redshirts, God forbid.